Friday, September 25, 2009

Assembly becomes a bad joke


The South Korean National Assembly has become the laughingstock of the world. To all appearances, we are an uncivilized nation because it has no idea what democracy and majority rule are all about. The BBC, The New York Times and the Wall Street Journal have all covered South Korean politicians engaging in fist fights.

The central cause of this problem is neglect of the democratic process. Legislators were blocked from entering the Assembly. Outside organizations broke into the National Assembly. Legislators who were present were physically impeded from voting on bills. In light of this disgrace, for anyone to question the legality of the bills passage is ludicrous.
Democratic Party members say they will step down from their legislative seats and fight from outside the Assembly. The National Assembly speaker should agree. Even within the party, there are opposing voices that urge against any political circus. The Grand National Party plans to form a task force on the National Assembly to study ways to prevent the disruption of the legislature. But no task force can guarantee that.

The brawl at the National Assembly wasn't due to the lack of a system. Answers can be easily found in the foreign media s coverage. In its editorial yesterday, the Wall Street Journal wrote that Korea s focus on political consensus has made it difficult for the ruling party to implement its platform over Democratic objections. To outsiders, majority rule is the logical choice. This time, consensus was emphasized more than was necessary.
At the root of democracy is majority rule. Respecting consensus is merely a noble trait of Korean politics that has been added. If we can make good use of it, we can compensate for flaws in parliamentary democracy. But we should never forget the basics and become the butt of jokes around the globe.



1 comment:

  1. I have to admit, the first I heard about Korea in my adult life was through one of the parliamentary fights. It is pretty common to see these fights on American TV as part of a joke. Taiwan is also popular for these shots.

    Of course, Americans can't make fun of anyone when it comes to stupid politicians :)

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.